Guided vs Self-Guided Treks
How to choose the best option for your next adventure!
Over the last few years I've gotten to explore some of the most incredible locations all over the world! From the historic sanctuary city of Machu Picchu to the Accursed Mountain Range in Albania to the famous Patagonian Glaciers, these treks have changed my life and the way I see the world.
However, in order to see these extraordinary locations, there are so many logistical pieces that have to come together, which is why I have participated in a multitude of Guided and Self-guided adventures. Each of these styles have their own strengths and weaknesses, and it's important to know what you are getting into before booking your trek.
So let's break it down:
What Is A Guided Tour/Trek?
A guided tour is a trekking style that will include a tour guide during your adventure, and usually includes you being a part of a group. The tour guide is usually a local or specifically educated person that can expertly guide and teach your group about your activity and the location you are in. Guided tours can also include a group of people you have curated yourself, a group of strangers that are gathered together for the tour, and a completely solo guided tour.
So Then What Is A Self-Guided Tour/Trek?
Self-guided tours are new offerings that many travel and trekking companies now offer that usually includes the company creating a template of the trek, that you then follow all on your own. This template can include access to an app that directs you throughout the trek, handouts with all your information, or an interactive portal with everything you need. Logistics are organized and confirmed ahead of time, but it is up to you to guide yourself through the hike, following the established plans. This can also be a solo experience, or an option for smaller groups of trekkers.
Is There A Third Option?
Technically yes, there is another option you can take: freestyle! This can include booking as you go, wildcamping, and a general style of flexibility. Trekkers can fly into basecamps or local towns nearby treks, do their own research, and use their own supplies to do a self-supported adventure. Honestly, I have never done this, myself, as it does not fit how I like to travel or my lifestyle. However, in every trek I have done, I have met many people who enjoy this approach to travel. This style is best for adventurers who crave flexibility, have extra time to adjust plans, and are experienced with their gear and various outdoor challenges. I will not be breaking down this option more, but know that this is absolutely an option in almost any location if it is something you would like to pursue!
The Pro's And The Con's
Both the Guided and Self-guided tours have their strengths and weaknesses, and it is important to understand these before choosing your adventure!
Guided Tours/Treks
Guided tours allow you to learn and engage much more with the local people, culture, and landscape. This is a good option for life-long-learners who want to fully appreciate every aspect of the trip.
Guided tours will create an immediate sense of community with the guide, yourself, and the other adventurers. This is great for first-time solo travelers and extroverts, but may become tiring for introverts or if your group is struggling to connect together.
Guided Tours require you to keep pace. This may mean that you are invited to slow down so others can keep up, or it may require you to push a little bit harder to stay with the group. The trek may include several stops for educational opportunities and usually includes a schedule that needs to be kept each day (expect early mornings!)
Guided tours are often a bigger financial investment, as you are paying (hopefully fairly + ethically) the guides and workers on your trek. This can be a con for those on a budget, or it can also be seen as a pro when considering that you are creating financial opportunities for local companies.
Guided tours will usually include additional amenities and support. Your guide can offer additional help when needed, your other trekkers can be an incredible encouragement when you are struggling, and guided tours overall seem to include thoughtful touches. This could include extra snacks, tailored stops along the way, and additional gear.
Self-Guided Tours/Treks
Self-guided tours are exactly that = self-guided. Trekkers should expect to fully understand their directions, locations, and itinerary before beginning. Thankfully, you will most likely find other lovely trekkers along the way that can help you as you go, it is important not to expect Hut hosts, other group leaders, or transportation workers to do additional work for you unless it is an emergency.
Self-guided tours give an incredible self of autonomy and freedom. Want to add a few extra miles for that view? Want to sleep in tomorrow before a short hiking day? Need to bail because you are sick? PERFECT. Self-guided tours can offer moderately experienced trekkers a whole new way to explore.
Self-guided tours require you to be good at technology and logistics. Most companies will give you an online portal or app for all the plans you may need. It is important to know how to read a map, understand distances and terrain, and have confidence to navigate new cities when doing a self-guided tour.
Self-guided tours are usually slightly cheaper than guided tours, as there are fewer workers involved in your prep (not none, just less).
Self-guided tours require a heightened understanding of safety for the trekker, as you have much fewer support systems available while on the trail.
Self-guided tours do end up creating a different type of community. Every single self-guided tour I have been on has eventually included me buddying up with other solo trekkers or finding friends at the hostels to play cards with and plan for the next day. It may take more effort to connect, but is always available for those searching!
So How Do You Decide What Is Best?
Other than just balancing the pros and cons list from above, it can be important to reflect on past travel experiences that you have had - big or small, don't sell past adventures short!
What were your favorite travel adventures? Were you alone, with friends, or with strangers? Did you plan the trip, or did you enjoy being the passenger princess? Reflect on a trip you did not enjoy. What was the most difficult part? What are non-negotiables for you when you are traveling? Do you have health considerations that require you to need additional support, or is it easier to keep your own schedule? What is the number one, most important thing that has to happen on this trip: You have to finish? You make new friends? You learn about the culture?
Use these reflections and questions as a guide to figure out what your priorities and values are. And remember to be realistic. Something will always go wrong while traveling - so what kind of adventure do you want to experience, even if it all goes sideways?
Here are some examples of trips I've been on to get your travel list going:
Salkantey Trek to Machu Picchu - Guided
5 day guided trek (my very first solo international trip!) with Salkantey Trekking
Patagonia W Trek - Self-Guided
4-5 day self-guided trek with Howlanders
PCT Section J Trek - Freestyle!
6 days
Historic Sights and Beer Tour in Prague - Guided
Incredible half-day tour in Prague with Viator
Peaks of the Balkans Trek - Self-Guided
10 day self-guided trek with Balkans Natural Adventure
Alta Via 2 Trek - Self-Guided with my Spouse
11 day self-guided trek with Bookatrekking
Happy Adventuring! Follow me on Instagram to see more of my adventures or for any questions you may have for your next trekking adventure!



Comments